Iridology: Another Alternative Medicine Scam

Updated 1/1/2019

Remember that prank where you would tell someone that you could tell if someone had cancer if their hand was bigger than their face? And then you’d smack their hand into their face when they tried to compare the two? Now imagine that someone told you that looking at your eye color could tell them if you had a broken foot. Sounds crazy, right?

Iridology is the process employed by some alternative-medicine practitioners where they attempt to divine medical problems by staring at your eyes. They have developed this into a full pseudo-science complete with training schools and certification programs. 

Where chiropractors and osteopaths claim that all diseases can be traced back to skeletal “imbalances,” iridologists believe that all diseases and ailments can be detected by observing the iris. Iridologists believe that the the oculomotor nerve somehow changes the iris to indicate disease and infirmity. They believe that the health of every organ can be determined by examining the color, shape, tint, and depth of fibers that make up the iris.

They say that the eyes are the gateways to the soul. Well, these guys take that a bit too literally.

iridology
I really wonder how they came up with these particular zones.

Iridologists generally believe that a dark area of the eye indicates a loss of nerve activity for that region. Oh, I should mention that the eye is divided radially into sections that indicate each major body area. How they came up with each slice, I have no idea. If dark areas mean loss of nerve activity, that means that light areas mean more activity such as pain.

Here’s the biggest problem with all of that: 
The iris doesn’t change a whole lot from birth until death. There’s enough of a variation over a decade to make biometric scanners a little iffy but there’s definitely no change detectable on the timescale that iridologists would need in order to give any credibility to their “profession.”

Here’s another major problem:
There is no evolutionary reason for the oculomotor nerve to be connected to every organ in the way that iridologists believe. It just doesn’t make sense. Any college anatomy class would show that this isn’t the case.

How do iridologists even exist? 
Part of the reason is that as there is no government licensing authority, there’s no burden of proof that their practices are effective. There’s no blood tests to confirm diagnoses. Iridologists don’t boast of successful clinical trials because there are none. Unfortunately, anyone can claim anything so long as there is a disclaimer that they’re not legally allowed to diagnose or treat an illness.

And so, we continue the fight against the woo…

The final nail in the coffin: Procedure problems that would invalidate every test iridologists perform regardless of the lack of science behind the test. 

In order for a test to be valid, it must be performed the same way using accurately calibrated equipment every time.

Iridologists typically conduct examinations using a penlight and their own judgement. No real tests. No records. Just looking at you. Only some use video recording equipment. In the examination room, the iridologist passes a penlight across the field of vision of the patient. As the penlight is passed at a different angle and at varying distance during each visit, a slightly different image of the iris will be recorded each time. This promotes confirmation bias to take over in suggesting that there was some change in the iris compared to the last visit.

On top of that, using a different penlight or the same penlight at a different battery charge level will change the hue of light being cast which, obviously, changes the exact iris color. That means different test results every time. The iridologists that use actual recording equipment will likely not place it at the exact same distance each time which also means a different iris illumination will be recorded. If all of that doesn’t confound the “test” enough, room lighting can drastically change the close-up appearance of an iris from room to room.

One former iridologist described his disillusionment with his profession coming from after he developed a mounted camera and lighting system. He discovered the truth that a basic anatomy class would have told him long ago: irises don’t change. After correcting for all of the previously mentioned variables, individual iris pictures taken over time appeared to be identical regardless of the current health of the individual. After a long moral quandary, he shut down his practice and began working towards an actual medical degree. Many (if not most) alternative-medicine practitioners really do want to help people. Unfortunately, they went down the wrong path at some point.

“But my alternative-medicine practitioner diagnosed me correctly!”
This is where cold-reading comes in. Cold-reading is the process that psychics and con-men use to divine information about an individual based on verbal and non-verbal cues. If a 20 year pack-a-day smoker comes in complaining of shortness of breath, constant coughing, bloody spittle, and general weakness there is a fair chance that they have lung cancer. It doesn’t take a doctor to guess what symptoms mean but it does take a doctor to correctly diagnose a problem and prescribe a remedy.

Therein lies the true danger of these alternative-medicine practitioners: Not getting the right medicine for a real problem. They can drain your wallet all day long without it mattering that much. However, when you cross over from eating herbs for “wellness” and into “trying to cure cancer with grass clippings” there is real harm being done. Because of taking a charlatan’s word for the correct course of treatment, real people die every day.

Ok, is there any truth to Iridology at all?
Nope. Numerous studies have shown that iridologists perform no better than random chance at determining healthy patients from sick patients.

Have any stories? Leave a comment. 

3 Responses

  1. Bron
    Bron at |

    So a mother doesn’t really know if her child is sick because she doesn’t employ ‘real tests’??
    Iridology is not about telling people what is ‘wrong’with them so the therapist can sell the client medicine- like the (not-so) orthodox medicine which is “practiced” today. The iris’ can reflect the condition of the organs so we may be able to take preventative measures, just as any other signs or symptoms may be interpreted. If your child is red in the face are you going to tend to him, or leave him because you don’t have accurately calibrated equipment?
    There is actually a lot of scientific proof of it’s effectiveness. It is not going to hurt (like radiology) so why worry?

    Down to earth Mum, Naturopath, Herbalist, Therapist and compassionate human being.

    Reply
    1. Jonathan Brandt
      Jonathan Brandt at |

      Eyes are not just windows into the soul, but also into the health and well-being of our delicate offspring!

      Reply